Short answer: Crenshaw Lakes is one of Lutz’s quiet luxury pockets: about 156 larger homes on big, tree-covered lots around private Lake Crenshaw, with little or no HOA. Expect to pay about $1 million and up.
Crenshaw Lakes at a glance
- Location: off US-41 via Crenshaw Lake Road, ZIP 33548
- Size: about 156 homes around private Lake Crenshaw (Momentum Realty)
- Median price: about $1.13 million over 12 months (Momentum Realty); about $1 million over two years, built 1964–2018 (Horizon Palm Realty)
- Lots: about half an acre to nearly 3 acres (Stellar MLS, 2026)
What the homes are like
Custom homes from the 1960s to 2018, many with 3,000–4,500 square feet, pools and docks. Older homes on big lakefront lots often sell as rebuild opportunities.
Getting around
The Veterans Expressway, Dale Mabry and US-41 are minutes away; Tampa International Airport is about 25 minutes.
What to check before you buy
- Septic inspection and age.
- Dock, seawall and lake access.
- Flood zone near the water.
- Roof and insurance on older homes.
Nearby neighborhoods to compare
- Cheval: guard-gated golf nearby
- Lake Keystone: a ski lake in Odessa
- Lake Padgett Estates: ski lakes with lower prices in Land O’ Lakes
Thinking about Crenshaw Lakes?
Tell me your budget and must-haves and I’ll send recent closed sales in Crenshaw Lakes, the current HOA and CDD numbers for the street you like, and how it compares with the rest of Lutz. You can also get an alert the moment a home here lists.